Debate: Is it ethical to disect specific players openly on the forum?

[GaF]

I've today created this thread - http://www.punterslounge.com/forum/f62/player-profiles-betfair-18k-gtd-flukesky-86152/ It is intended to be the first of many. Posts 17-21 express concerns from other PLrs about the thread. I confess I did wrestle with the moral implications a little before doing it, however, from the fact I put the thread up, you can see the conclusions I came to. I'd like to understand a bit more about what the specific objections are, to see if there's a way we can keep doing it whilst keeping everyone happy we're not stepping over the line. Would it be better if we did the same thing but disguised aliases (with only those involved knowing who the players really were? Would it be ok if we kept the discussions going, but in private, rather than in public? Or is the very fact of collectively working over old data the issue?

[SteveO]

Re: Debate: Is it ethical to disect specific players openly on the forum? Gaf people discuss hand histories via email and MSN all the time. Highlighting specific players in this forum is only a bad thing I reckon.