Nadal Discussion

[fishy25]

Although what i am about to say has nothing to do with what you posted here, i am here to recall our chat during the recent french open. Turns out

'Nadal's trade won't work on other surfaces?' was spot on afterall. I know, Nadal has played 5 finals here in SW19. But you what the cliche is? "You are only so good as your previous match". Nadal was LUCKY he even won the first set. It is a pity Rosol didnt beat him in three sorry sets.

You're basing this on one match and not the big picture. Nadal has still made 5 finals, winning it twice so there's still literally no argument for you to say his 'trade doesn't work on other surfaces.' You don't beat Murray 3 times out of 3 and Federer if your game isn't effective on the grass. Andy Murray has lost to Donald Young in the past. Does that mean Murray isn't effective on the hard courts? One match doesn't mean anything :eyes

[caligulaxx]

Re: Wimbledon 2012

You're basing this on one match and not the big picture. Nadal has still made 5 finals' date=' winning it twice so there's still literally no argument for you to say his 'trade doesn't work on other surfaces.' You don't beat Murray 3 times out of 3 and Federer if your game isn't effective on the grass. Andy Murray has lost to Donald Young in the past. Does that mean Murray isn't effective on the hard courts? One match doesn't mean anything :eyes[/quote'] That's true i'll give you that but i also recall him losing in recent times to the likes of Ivan Dodig (who had his breakthrough year last year, before that hardly anyone knew him), Floryan Mayer, Kohlschreiber, now Rosol. Rafa may be the king on clay but i don't see him winning any more masters or GS on other surfaces. Just my own thoughts though i don't expect people to agree with me :loon